83 Pencil Mill Road, Castleton, VT, 05735

Price Reduction

Address

83 Pencil Mill Road, Castleton, VT

Listing Type

Single Family

Price

$ 399,900

Your Agent

Michelle Benedict

Transaction Manager | Notary

802-523-3159

Property Attributes

MLS#5101465
TypeSingle Family
Listing Status Active
CountyRUTLAND
CityCastleton
AreaRutland
NeighborhoodBomoseen Lake
Zip05735
StyleSplit Level
Year Built1975
Price$ 399,900
Bedrooms3
Full Bathrooms1
Half Bathrooms1
Sqr Footage1882
Lot Size2.08 Acres

Data Source:

PrimeMLS

Property Description

Deeded Lake Access!! Welcome to your Vermont retreat! Nestled on over 2 private, wooded acres, this beautifully renovated single family home offers the perfect blend of modern comfort and natural beauty. Thoughtfully updated throughout, the home features stylish finishes, an inviting layout, and move in ready convenience. Upgrades include all new flooring, heating system, new roof, appliances, bathrooms and the list goes on!! Additional energy updates including blower door testing were completed on this gorgeous home. Surrounded by mature trees, the property provides exceptional privacy while remaining just minutes from the crystal-clear waters of Lake Bomoseen. Take a walk on the path to the open adjoining 30 acres. Enjoy all that lake living has to offer with deeded lake access, including the rare convenience of Boat Slip #59, making it easy to spend your days boating, fishing, swimming, or simply taking in the scenic beauty of Vermont's largest freshwater lake. Whether you're searching for a year-round residence, a vacation getaway, or an investment opportunity, this exceptional property delivers the best of both worlds: peaceful woodland living with effortless access to one of the area's premier recreational destinations. Don't miss this opportunity to own a turnkey home in one of Vermont's most desirable lake communities.

Elementary School	Middle School	High School
Castleton Elementary School	Fair Haven Grade School Middle School	Fair Haven UHSD #16 High School

Price History
7/23/2026	Listed $449,900
8/11/2026	6$424,900
9/1/2026	6$399,900

General Features

Road Frontage	Yes
Sewer	1000 Gallon,Septic
Heating	Propane,Baseboard
Cooling	None
Utilities	Cable Available,Telephone Available
Possession	At Closing
Roof	Asphalt Shingle
Appliances	Dishwasher,Microwave,Refrigerator,Electric Stove,Exhaust Fan
Easements	Unknown
Garage	Yes
Flood Zone	No
Zoning	residential
Full Baths	1
Half Baths	1
Bathrooms	2
Year Built	1975
Electric	Circuit Breaker(s)
Style	Split Level
Stories Count	3
Resort	No
Type	Single Family
Property Condition	Existing
Tax Year	2026
Electric Company	Green Mountain Power
Covenants	Unknown
Construction Materials	Wood Frame,Wood Siding
Directions	From Castleton 4 Corners take Route 30 North. Travel along Bomoseen to a right turn onto North Road. Take second left onto Pencil Mill. Property on left. See mailbox and sign.
High School	Fair Haven UHSD #16
City	Castleton
Property Class	Residential
School District	Slate Valley Unified School District
Seasonal	No
Elementary School	Castleton Elementary School
Middle School	Fair Haven Grade School
DOM	49
Price Per Sq Ft Total AG	340.05
Last Updated	09/01/2026 16:24:51

Interior Features

Basement Description	Insulated,Partially Finished
Interior Amenities	2 Fireplaces
Basement	Yes
Flooring	Carpet,Laminate,Slate/Stone
Beds	3
Total Rooms	5
Total Number of Units	1
Room 1 Level	2
Internet	Fiber Optic Internt Avail,High Speed Intrnt Avail
Total Finished Area	1882
Rooms: Level B	Level B: Laundry Room,Level B: Other,Level B: Rec Room
Rooms: Level 3	Level 3: Bedroom,Level 3: Full Bathroom
Rooms: Level 2	Level 2: Dining Room,Level 2: Family Room,Level 2: Kitchen
Rooms: Level 1	Level 1: 1/2 Bathroom,Level 1: Foyer,Level 1: Living Room
Room 9 Type	Living Room
Room 9 Level	1
Room 9 Dimensions	12 x 21.8
Room 8 Type	Foyer
Room 8 Level	1
Room 8 Dimensions	8.4 12.2
Room 7 Type	Bathroom Full
Room 7 Level	3
Room 7 Dimensions	13.1 x 7.0
Room 6 Type	Bedroom
Room 6 Level	3
Room 6 Dimensions	14.3 x 12
Room 5 Type	Bedroom
Room 5 Level	3
Room 5 Dimensions	10.10 x 13.2
Room 4 Type	Bedroom
Room 4 Level	3
Room 4 Dimensions	9.5 x 13.2
Room 3 Type	Kitchen
Room 3 Level	2
Room 3 Dimensions	13.1 x 9.8
Room 2 Type	Dining Room
Room 2 Level	2
Room 2 Dimensions	8.11 x 13.5
Room 13 Type	Other
Room 13 Level	Basement
Room 13 Dimensions	21.8 x 25.6
Room 12 Type	Laundry Room
Room 12 Level	Basement
Room 12 Dimensions	19 x 16.10
Room 11 Type	Rec Room
Room 11 Level	Basement
Room 11 Dimensions	19 x 21.1
Room 10 Type	Bathroom Half
Room 10 Level	1
Room 10 Dimensions	13.1 x 7
Room 1 Type	Family Room
Room 1 Dimensions	19.0 x 12.1
Basement Access Type	Interior

Exterior Features

Lot Features	Country Setting,Recreational,Walking Trails,Wooded,Near Golf Course,Near Paths,Near Shopping,Near Skiing,Near Snowmobile Trails
Exterior Amenities	Boat Slip/Dock,Garden Space,Covered Porch,ROW to Water
Driveway	Gravel
Lot Size Area	2.08
Water Source	Drilled Well
Parking Features	Driveway,Garage
Garage Capacity	1
Water Body Name	Bomoseen Lake
Foundation	Concrete
Color	Brown
Waterfront Property	No
Road Frontage Length	200
Road Frontage Type	Gravel,Public
Surveyed	Unknown
Water Body Type	Lake
Lot Size Square Feet	90605
Water Body Access	Yes
Water Access Details	Deep Water Access,Dock Access,Indirect,Not Adjoining